Saturday, November 3, 2012

Bobbi Brown Forest Metallic Eye Shadow review + swatches


          With the holiday season just around the corner, I've been loving everything pine themed and pine scented. Inspired by the idea of pine trees, I decided to share a review of my Bobbi Brown Metallic Eye Shadow in Forest with you today, as well as a few needles from a very special tree.


       The green needles in my photos are from no ordinary tree. They're from Frosty, a pine tree from my childhood. (My parents brought me the branch shown here during their recent trip to Chicago). In elementary school, all the kids were given a white pine seedling on Earth Day. I named mine Frosty (yes, after the snowman) and planted him in our garden. As the garden fell fallow over the years and I left home, my little twig grew, grew, and grew! Two decades later, Frosty is a magnificent tree. He's twenty feet tall and has plenty of branches with  long graceful pine needles. Unfortunately, Frosty wasn't planted in the best position, and will eventually have to be cut down because of it. I'm quite torn up about this, and it makes me teary eyed every time I think about it. After all, this is a tree that grew up with me.  In a way, I'm hoping that this blog post is a way for Frosty to live on in my memories.


         I've had my Bobbi  Brown Metallic Eye Shadow in Forest for quite some time now. It was one of the first Bobbi Brown eyeshadows that I purchased for myself, so it's fitting to feature it alongside my favorite tree. Bobbi Brown eyeshadows pop conveniently out of their single casing and easily into larger palettes. I have the two, three, and six pan sizes. A four pan size is also available and my mom has a limited edition nine-pan size. I think Bobbi's palette system is one of the best systems out there; there's no scratching or prying necessary and you can see the name of the shadow on the back of the palette.



          Bobbi Brown Forest Metallic Eye Shadow is a rich blackened olive gold with shimmer that gives the impression of a forest at dusk. It's not overtly green, as one might expect from the name. The formula is smooth and pigmented as one would expect of Bobbi Brown shadows. I've compared it to swatches of a few greenish colors to give you a good idea of what it looks like. Urban Decay Loaded (from the Dangerous palette) is a similar intensity and more blue-green. Bobbi  Brown Sage Metallic Eyes Shadow is much lighter green-grey. Urban Decay Jagged (from the Vice palette) has a similar blackened gold feel, however it's lighter and less olive. It's also less pigmented and has some large glitter mixed in.


         Bobbi Brown Forest Metallic Eye Shadow is a gorgeous blackened olive shadow that works well for the current season. In my imagination, the color conjures up the shadows of greener places outside the city, including that small patch of earth hundreds of miles away where Frosty laid down his roots. Thanks for reading! What Bobbi Brown eyeshadows do you have in your collection? What are your favorite deep greens or olive eyeshadows? Do you have a tree or plant that has a special significance to you?

Love, Dovey.

22 comments:

  1. Is it similar to NARS' Mekong in any way? :)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Maria, Thanks for asking--- I do believe it's quite different. Forest is a blackened gold which in combination gives off a greenish glow. Mekong is more like a chocolate brown with shimmer :)

      Delete
  2. Aww I love the story about Frosty! So sorry it has to go too :( The memory will live on in this beautiful post though!

    Forest looks like my kind of shade! I think it's in a similar to Black Topaz (in the Black Caviar palette), but lighter and greener. Darn, why can I own so many similar shades already but never feel I have enough ;)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Sunny! Thanks! I really love the tree. As for the color, I think so--- you look beautiful in golds :)

      Delete
  3. Lovely color. It probably matches any skin tone too. How convenient is the packaging!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Girlie Blogger, I love palette packaging and I think this is among the best!

      Delete
  4. This is a gorgeous shadow--I love the hint of smoky green. It reminds me a bit of the darker shade in the Hourglass Dune duo though--which I have. If this one was a touch more green, I would get it! Otherwise I think it's too similar

    Also, REALLY sorry to hear about Frosty, Dovey. That was a lovely story though and at least you and your family with always have those wonderful memories!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Becca, I think you might be right--- it is of the Dune variety! Thank you so much for the kind words on Frosty; I do hope to think of it in that optimistic light!

      Delete
  5. I'm sorry about Frosty.

    I haven't tried Bobbi Brown eyeshadows, only the gel liners, but it looks beautiful!

    xx

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Coco, Thanks for the note about Frosty; hopefully he'll get to stay around a bit longer. I love the gel liners too!

      Delete
  6. Forest is gorgeous! I don't have any single BB shades - but I am a big fan of BB holiday palettes and have my eye on the Caviar set which seems to have similar dark shimmery olive tones in it. If I don't get the palette, I might have to snag Forest if it's still available. :)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Liz, Thank you! Oh, the holiday palettes always get to me. I love the name 'Caviar' and I've been eyeing that as well :) I think Forest is a permanent color, though they do shuffle the in and out once in a while!

      Delete
  7. Awww, poor Frosty! That story was so heart-warming. May he forever live on in our hearts. :')

    This is such a rich olive green! Picturing it smoked out all over the lid and with a deep/red lip color -- so festive. I think I have at most 2 green eyeshadows and they're all from one palette, which doesn't really count. I think I might have to look into greens soon!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Maggie, Thanks for the kind words on Frosty, he means a lot to me :) I love the look you've imagined, though I don't think I would dare pull it off!

      Delete
  8. So sorry to hear that Frosty may have to go soon : ( But what a wonderful memory - I got a bit teary eyed as well. I'm a long time fan of Bobbi Brown - this is a gorgeous color!

    ReplyDelete
  9. Aw, Frosty sounds like a beautiful tree, may his memory live on.
    Forest looks like a great shade, especially for the fall season. I have a dark olive-green from Laura Mercier called Pine Bronze that I like a lot -- it seems like it might be similar to Forest.

    ReplyDelete
  10. It looks pretty and looks like it applies smoothly. I love how it looks, but I still prefer Urban Decay Jagged from the Vice Palette :)

    ReplyDelete
  11. I love the photography here and that the tree has such lovely memories for you makes the pictures even more appealing. I love the Bobbi Brown color but think I prefer the Urban Decay Jagged and may go out and by it tomorrow as I have a wedding this weekend I would like to wear it for. :) Thanks!

    ReplyDelete
  12. Maybe you should plant another one that does not grow too big and you can name that one Frosty Jr.:)

    ReplyDelete
  13. Aww! FROSTY!! I can't believe your tree lasted so long! That is amazing, actually. Also, it is super nice of your parents to bring you a branch. :) I haven't bought any bobbi brown eyeshadow singles, but I always wanted to and I always though the palette system seemed nice. :)

    ReplyDelete
  14. What a really great shade! I'm totally into greens, but somehow seem to forget about them again and again. Always using the nudes in my collection... but I'll make sure to stop by my local Bobbi counter and try this gorgeous green :)

    Thanks for sharing these beautiful pictures!

    ReplyDelete
  15. Thank you for the delightful story about Frosty. I'll smile whenever I think about it :-)

    ReplyDelete

Thank you for taking the time to comment! I truly enjoy hearing your thoughts!

Comments are moderated to prevent spam. Please note that links, promotions, and offensive / irrelevant / questionable comments will be deleted at my discretion.